Prep Right
Argument evidence · Tier 1

Much labour shift was into low-productivity construction, trade, transport and other services.

E429 · CSS Evidence Bank v1
This cardThe cardWhat it provesPairs with (3)In chains (2)
Much labour shift was into low-productivity construction, trade, transport and other services. · 2025World Bank · 2025Source named — not yet verified
Source

World Bank — https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/feature/2025/10/17/fragile-gains-enduring-challenges-charting-pakistan-s-path-out-of-poverty. Verified in source set / retroactive normalization pending.

What it proves

Pakistan saw structural change without sufficient productivity transformation.

Draft — not reviewed

What it does not prove: Low productivity relative to manufacturing does not mean these jobs paid worse than the farm work they replaced — this is the very shift the World Bank credits with driving the long-run poverty fall. The claim is about the composition and productivity level of the destination sectors, not that structural change was a mistake.

Memory hook: Construction, trade, transport → exit from farming without the productivity jump

Rebuts the claim: "A rising services share of employment shows Pakistan is modernising its economy" — the shift was into low-productivity services, not high-value ones.

Pairs with

In chains and maps