2026
According to Conflict Theory, crime is a product of social inequality. In your opinion how relevant is this perspective for understanding the nature and patterns of crime in developing countries such as Pakistan.
(20)
Debate #20 · Society, social change and institutions
Is crime in Pakistan driven more by inequality or by weak social control?
This debate
All debatesAsked beforeQuestions (8)Evidence (4)PositionsSame themeIs Pakistan's family system breaking down or adapting to social change?Have globalisation and digital media eroded or enriched Pakistan's culture and social fabric?Should the state limit individual liberty for the sake of order?Asked before
- 00
- 01
- 02
- 03
- 04
- 05
- 06
- 07
- 08
- 09
- 10
- 11
- 12
- 13
- 14
- 15
- 16
- 17
- 18
- 19
- 20
- 21
- 22
- 23
- 24
- 25
- 26
Examiners want: Causes of crime and deviance, conflict versus control explanations, loss of trust in institutions, flaws in formal and informal control, reforms
The questions
2026
Discuss how declining public trust in institutions can contribute to deviant behaviour, non-cooperation, and social resistance in Pakistani society.
(20)
2023
How does the concept of deviance challenge and reinforce social order, and what role do social norms and values play in defining deviant behavior?
(20)
2022
Deviant Behaviour is the result of ineffective social control. Comment on the flaws existing in the formal and informal mechanisms of social control with examples and add that how these mechanisms can be improved.
(20)
2021
In what ways does informal and formal social control help to reduce or prevent deviance and crime in society?
(20)
2019
What is Crime and Deviance? Explain the major causes of crime, with reference to Pakistani society.
(20)
2015
Define the term “Social Problem” and discuss Crime as a Social Problem?
(20)
2009
Define the term “Social Problem". Discuss smuggling as a social problem in a society.
(20)
Evidence you can cite
Financial fraud generated 35,945 complaints in 2024, largest FIA cybercrime category. (2024)FIAFIA reported 15 Cyber Crime Wing field circles in 2024 structure. (2024)FIAFIA registered 46,399 enquiries and 10,387 cases in 2024. (2024)FIATrafficking/smuggling awareness campaign focused on 31 high-risk districts and was associated with 32,402 FIA helpline c (2024)UNODC
Positions and chains
“For” argues: Crime in Pakistan is driven more by inequality than by weak social control.
For · thesisCrime in Pakistan grows from deep, spatially concentrated and politically produced inequality, as conflict theory predicts; weak control is a symptom of that inequality.
◆ Claim ModerateReported crime and robberies surged in the same years measured inequality rose and poverty returned.
▲ EvidenceTotal crimes reported in Pakistan, 2024 vs 2015: 1511238 crimes reported in 2024 (633600 in 2015) (2015 and 2024)Pakistan Bureau of Statistics, Crime Report table (source: National Police Bureau, Ministry of Interior)Gini index of income inequality, Pakistan: 33.5 (29.6 in 2018) (2024)World Bank, World Development Indicators (SI.POV.GINI)Robbery cases reported in Pakistan, 2022 to 2023: 41020 in 2022; 78912 in 2023 (2022-2023)Pakistan Bureau of Statistics, Crimes Reported by Type and Provinces (source: National Police Bureau, Ministry of Interior)Poverty began rising again from around 2020 amid COVID, inflation, floods and macro stress. (2020 onward)World Bank
→ WarrantReported crime rose from 633600 in 2015 to 1511238 in 2024, the Gini rose from 29.6 in 2018 to 33.5, and robberies went from 41020 in 2022 to 78912 in 2023 as poverty rose again.
✦ PakistanThe coincidence of economic stress and a property-crime surge fits strain and conflict accounts, though it is correlation and reported totals also reflect better recording.
◆ Claim ModerateInequality is produced by elite privilege and policy, the core conflict-theory claim that law and order serve the powerful.
▲ EvidenceOlder UNDP study estimated elite-group privileges at Rs2.66tn, about 8% of GDP at the time. (2020-21)UNDPUNDP frames inequality through the '3 Ps': Power, People and Policy. (2020-21)UNDP
→ WarrantUNDP estimated elite-group privileges at Rs2.66tn, about 8% of GDP, and frames inequality through power, people and policy, showing that inequality is made by institutions, not chance.
✦ PakistanIf privilege is built into policy, the poor experience both more deprivation and more policing, which conflict theory sees as the root of crime patterns.
◆ Claim ContestedLong-run studies of Pakistan link poverty, and in one study inequality, to higher crime, though the evidence on inequality itself is split.
▲ EvidenceIncome inequality, poverty and crime nexus in Pakistan, 1984-2012: In the long run, poverty, income inequality and inflation have a positive and significant impact on crime (2016 (data 1984-2012))Muhammad Ahad, International Journal of Economics and Empirical Research 4(3), 133-145Socio-economic determinants of crime in Pakistan, 1973-2014 (ARDL study): Poverty had a positive and significant long-run effect on property crime; income inequality was not significant; police strength had a negative and significant effect on aggregate crime (2017 (data 1973-2014))Anwar, Arshed and Anwar, International Journal of Economics and Financial Issues 7(1), 312-322
→ WarrantA study of 1984-2012 finds poverty, income inequality and inflation raise crime in the long run; a 1973-2014 study confirms poverty raises property crime but finds inequality not significant.
✦ PakistanThe strongest Pakistani evidence is for poverty driving property crime; the inequality link is plausible but unsettled, so candidates should claim it with care.
◆ Claim ContestedDeprivation is geographically concentrated, producing regional grievance and exclusion that can sustain crime and violence.
▲ EvidencePoverty ranged from ~3.5% in Islamabad to 76.9% in Tharparkar in World Bank spatial analysis. (2025)World BankSeven of ten poorest districts in analysis were in Balochistan. (2025)World BankRural poverty: 36.2% (2024-25)Pakistan Economic SurveyUrban poverty: 17.4% (2024-25)Pakistan Economic Survey
→ WarrantPoverty ranges from about 3.5% in Islamabad to 76.9% in Tharparkar, and rural poverty (36.2%) is double urban (17.4%); such gaps fuel the exclusion conflict theory ties to deviance.
✦ PakistanSeven of ten poorest districts lie in Balochistan, where exclusion overlaps with weak integration into the state.
✕ Strongest counterMurders fell from 13937 in 2013 to 11074 in 2024 even as hardship persisted, and a 1973-2014 study finds inequality not significant while police strength lowers crime: the control side fits the data better.Murders reported in Pakistan, 2024 vs 2013: 11074 murders in 2024 (13937 in 2013) (2013 and 2024)Pakistan Bureau of Statistics, Crime Report table (source: National Police Bureau, Ministry of Interior)Socio-economic determinants of crime in Pakistan, 1973-2014 (ARDL study): Poverty had a positive and significant long-run effect on property crime; income inequality was not significant; police strength had a negative and significant effect on aggregate crime (2017 (data 1973-2014))Anwar, Arshed and Anwar, International Journal of Economics and Financial Issues 7(1), 312-322
↺ RebuttalProperty crime is the bulk of the rise, and that same study finds poverty significantly raises it; another study finds inequality significant over 1984-2012. Murders falling reflects state action on violence, not on the motives behind theft.Socio-economic determinants of crime in Pakistan, 1973-2014 (ARDL study): Poverty had a positive and significant long-run effect on property crime; income inequality was not significant; police strength had a negative and significant effect on aggregate crime (2017 (data 1973-2014))Anwar, Arshed and Anwar, International Journal of Economics and Financial Issues 7(1), 312-322Income inequality, poverty and crime nexus in Pakistan, 1984-2012: In the long run, poverty, income inequality and inflation have a positive and significant impact on crime (2016 (data 1984-2012))Muhammad Ahad, International Journal of Economics and Empirical Research 4(3), 133-145
Way forwardTackle the roots of crime by narrowing regional and elite-driven inequality through jobs, targeted social protection and fairer policy, not by policing alone.
Terms to define
Crime: a legally punishable norm violation; deviance: any breach of norms; inequality: unequal income, power and life chances; social control: formal (police, courts) and informal (family, community) checks on deviance.
Theories that help (3)
- Conflict theory: Crime reflects social inequality; the powerful define and enforce law in their interest, so the poor are both more pressured and more policed. Serves “Structural inequality”.
- Social control and deterrence theory: People conform when bonds to family, community and institutions are strong and sanctions are certain; deviance rises when these checks weaken. Serves “Weak social control”.
- Routine activity theory: Crime occurs when a motivated offender meets a suitable target without a capable guardian, so opportunity and guardianship shape crime patterns. Serves “Interacting causes”.
Drafted by Claude from the evidence bank; not reviewed. Every chain cites the bank or the timeline; figures appear only as the source gives them.
News about this debate watches for: street crime, karachi police, punjab police, fir, smuggling, katcha area, mob lynching, prison reform, conviction rate, anti-terrorism courts, safe city, cybercrime, fia.